Comments on: Naxal menace – Who will bell the cat ? http://www.gingerchai.com/2009/10/08/naxal-menace-who-will-bell-the-cat/ You. Me. We. Wed, 08 Feb 2012 16:13:43 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.2.1 By: Lakshmi Rajanhttp://www.gingerchai.com/2009/10/08/naxal-menace-who-will-bell-the-cat/comment-page-1/#comment-1979 Lakshmi Rajan Sun, 01 Nov 2009 03:14:40 +0000 http://www.gingerchai.com/2009/10/08/naxal-menace-who-will-bell-the-cat/#comment-1979 Thanks for the comprehensive commenting.About yout ideology of Naxalism. I would still stick to my notion that Naxalism as an idea has come to a dead end. Yes there might be still people who have an ideology but much of the cadre and leaders now spearheading have one idea that is to spread violence not for any cause (as they may claim)About your take on police force. As i mentioned in my topic.What matters at the end of the day is approach to the problem. We may have good IPS officers but do our politicians and beurocrats "use" the good brains ? Answer is no. The good brains are wasted. Secondly, our police force needs a "image make over" as i mentioned in the article.Having said that, yes there are recruits? I have answered that in my lost point. When we alienate a section of population they become a easy harvesting field for handlers. Thanks for the comprehensive commenting.

About yout ideology of Naxalism. I would still stick to my notion that Naxalism as an idea has come to a dead end. Yes there might be still people who have an ideology but much of the cadre and leaders now spearheading have one idea that is to spread violence not for any cause (as they may claim)

About your take on police force. As i mentioned in my topic.What matters at the end of the day is approach to the problem. We may have good IPS officers but do our politicians and beurocrats “use” the good brains ? Answer is no. The good brains are wasted. Secondly, our police force needs a “image make over” as i mentioned in the article.

Having said that, yes there are recruits? I have answered that in my lost point. When we alienate a section of population they become a easy harvesting field for handlers.

]]> By: Uttam Peguhttp://www.gingerchai.com/2009/10/08/naxal-menace-who-will-bell-the-cat/comment-page-1/#comment-1975 Uttam Pegu Sat, 31 Oct 2009 19:39:51 +0000 http://www.gingerchai.com/2009/10/08/naxal-menace-who-will-bell-the-cat/#comment-1975 I disagree with first 4 points to counter Naxal problems.Naxalism has become an idea and idea can not killed with gun. IF military might could finish off a struggle fought by dedicated and highly motivated people, USA would have finished off with Taliban, al Qaida long ago. Also India would have finished off with insurgency in North East India as well as in in Kashmir. Though it could finish militancy in Punjab by force, the force was not the only reason.Indian Police forces already have very good IPS officers who are able and well trained leaders. They should be enough to counter any brain behind poor and uneducated tribal posing as Naxalites.GOI should try to cut the supply line of Naxalite cadres. How Naxalites are getting new recruits year after year ? Many people argue that, if malls in cities were not in need of air conditioning, most probably, no one from cities or government would have entered those areas where tribal had been living for centuries, let alone try to establish power generating industries... I disagree with first 4 points to counter Naxal problems.

Naxalism has become an idea and idea can not killed with gun. IF military might could finish off a struggle fought by dedicated and highly motivated people, USA would have finished off with Taliban, al Qaida long ago. Also India would have finished off with insurgency in North East India as well as in in Kashmir. Though it could finish militancy in Punjab by force, the force was not the only reason.

Indian Police forces already have very good IPS officers who are able and well trained leaders. They should be enough to counter any brain behind poor and uneducated tribal posing as Naxalites.

GOI should try to cut the supply line of Naxalite cadres. How Naxalites are getting new recruits year after year ? Many people argue that, if malls in cities were not in need of air conditioning, most probably, no one from cities or government would have entered those areas where tribal had been living for centuries, let alone try to establish power generating industries…

]]> By: Lakshmi Rajanhttp://www.gingerchai.com/2009/10/08/naxal-menace-who-will-bell-the-cat/comment-page-1/#comment-1615 Lakshmi Rajan Tue, 13 Oct 2009 10:59:51 +0000 http://www.gingerchai.com/2009/10/08/naxal-menace-who-will-bell-the-cat/#comment-1615 Yes, I have mentiond it in the point 3 , Infact along with COBRA there is also Grey Hound force. What we need is more strength and bites to this specialized forces , coordinated with various agencies. Yes, I have mentiond it in the point 3 , Infact along with COBRA there is also Grey Hound force. What we need is more strength and bites to this specialized forces , coordinated with various agencies.

]]> By: Dhimanhttp://www.gingerchai.com/2009/10/08/naxal-menace-who-will-bell-the-cat/comment-page-1/#comment-1611 Dhiman Tue, 13 Oct 2009 07:31:57 +0000 http://www.gingerchai.com/2009/10/08/naxal-menace-who-will-bell-the-cat/#comment-1611 I think a specialized force by the name of COBRA(Combat Battalion for Resolute Action ) has been already operational under command and control of CRPF... they are an elite force trained and specialized in Jungle warfare specifically created to combat the Maoists ...I think GOI is contemplating an action of the joint paramilitary forces along with help from IAF .... plus they are taking the several development issues ...let us see how it all turns out... I think a specialized force by the name of COBRA(Combat Battalion for Resolute Action ) has been already operational under command and control of CRPF… they are an elite force trained and specialized in Jungle warfare specifically created to combat the Maoists …I think GOI is contemplating an action of the joint paramilitary forces along with help from IAF …. plus they are taking the several development issues …let us see how it all turns out…

]]> By: chetanhttp://www.gingerchai.com/2009/10/08/naxal-menace-who-will-bell-the-cat/comment-page-1/#comment-1569 chetan Sat, 10 Oct 2009 14:54:56 +0000 http://www.gingerchai.com/2009/10/08/naxal-menace-who-will-bell-the-cat/#comment-1569 a good topic to discuss, and also because not every one is aware of such conditions in the country There should be efforts to make common people know about this, because i feel that it is with the help of all that all the problems can be solved keep smiling! a good topic to discuss, and also because not every one is aware of such conditions in the country
There should be efforts to make common people know about this, because i feel that it is with the help of all that all the problems can be solved
keep smiling!

]]> By: sharathttp://www.gingerchai.com/2009/10/08/naxal-menace-who-will-bell-the-cat/comment-page-1/#comment-1532 sharat Fri, 09 Oct 2009 05:58:31 +0000 http://www.gingerchai.com/2009/10/08/naxal-menace-who-will-bell-the-cat/#comment-1532 India is a soft state...that's why when their leaders are arrested the so called intellects stand by them... they blabb about Human Rights....delay and try to influence the law to take its course....vote bank politics is devisive and this is the recation of this hate politics...tacle naxalism and terrorism with strong arms as these mutually pose a danger to The Nation India India is a soft state…that’s why when their leaders are arrested the so called intellects stand by them… they blabb about Human Rights….delay and try to influence the law to take its course….vote bank politics is devisive and this is the recation of this hate politics…tacle naxalism and terrorism with strong arms as these mutually pose a danger to The Nation India

]]>